I can’t help myself I’m not looking for them but they keep appearing before me. I tried to make them go away with a quick social media post. But they continue to haunt me wanting their own post. Earlier blog post touching on these instruments.
I want to say something about child labor, but really I just want to stop thinking about organs more. Maybe I’ll come back to this in future.
I didn’t know this gold coin before today. (is it real?) P(opuli) R(omani) SIGNA = these things are signs of the Roman people (i.e. not the emperor, not the senate, but us! the people). I mean it is just rhetoric and we know that even the men making these coins wanted to be autocrats and yet, I still find myself so hopeful when I see them. To believe in an alternate history for just a moment.
I want to thing about the dots from the birds mouth more. And also the altar. But not today.
It is not news that the lituus and wreath are symbols of the augurship, the Roman priestly college tasks with watching for portents especially from birds.
By-the-by you really should read/acquire for reference:
Gruchalski, Jakub. The Magisterial Auspices in Late Republican Rome. Historia Einzelschriften 282. (2026).
It’s so good.
Anyway, today it dawned on me that perhaps I’ve been thinking about wreaths as border on coins wrongly.
Balance scale with counterweights in form of the bust of a figure.
Now in Naples Archaeological Museum. Inventory number 74054.
See Pagano, M. and Prisciandaro, R., 2006. Studio sulle provenienze degli oggetti rinvenuti negli scavi borbonici del regno di Napoli. Naples: Nicola Longobardi, (p.79), Rami Inediti 85, and Pompeianarum Antiquitatum Historia, 1,2,1, see above.
Image research is impossible on a writing day. It slows everything down.
BM 1849,0623.3. “Curator’s comments: Etruscan style. Furtwaengler identifies the owner of the gem, Annia Augusta, with the widow of a distinguished Roman of the Republican period.” “Description: Banded onyx elongated scarab engraved with a draped bearded priest holding out a sacrificial vessel with a chain attached; in front is an altar with a situla (?) on top and a branch beside it. There is an inscription.”
The BM dates 3rd century BCE. I can find no scholarly publication using Google Scholar. It is not in Epigraphic Database Clauss-Slaby (EDCS).
The inscription is clearly Greek not Latin, but the gens is Latin.
CEBACTH or sebaste for Augusta is very imperial but the gem looks v 3rd century CE.
The impression doesn’t show the liquid falling from the cup that is visible on the gem.
The panel on the right with the wax tablets and the money bag is the perfect representation to go with some of my future talks hence it gets dropped in here. The plow and team of oxen and reel and distaff are also pretty awesome symbols of encoded Roman virtues. Gotta go back to another task but don’t want to lose this accidental find.
How familiar were the Romans with this god in the Roman republic? I’ve come up empty handed and gotten stuck on the question.
First who is he? Mostly associated with the East and popular with Soldiers. Likes to stand around on the back of bulls. Fond of double headed axes. Associated with storms. Mostly discussed as a mystery cult god of the high empire, like the better known Mithras or Isis. You know the drill, foreign, exotic, but not TOO foreign. Wikipedia entry.
The symbols of this gem are identical to those of Papius RRC 384/1 no. 13.
Augustan Age is easier to establish via literature. Harrison’s 1991 commentary on Vergil Book 10 doesn’t discuss the god (yes, I’m disappointed), but I believe the allusion is there:
The intent seems certainly to invoke an eastern god as the origin of an eastern hero, BUT this is not a traditional reading.
Epigraphic evidence suggests Dolichenus was associated with Jupiter Optimus Maximus before 50 CE, perhaps as early as Augustus’ reign.
Both from Trieste (EDCS-13700414 and EDCS-04600005). I wonder if the cognomen Heorte may suggest an eastern origin of this woman.
In the mid first century CE on the northern frontier two women give thanks for their freedom to I.O.M.D (EDCS-14500089). The name Dolichenus is restored and likely correct suggesting the god is so well known there is no need to spell out the name.
The earliest inscription in Rome itself of this syncretism is firmly dated to 92 BCE. (EDCS-29200149). There is no doubt about the syncretism possible with the names spelled out in full:
Iovi Optimo Maximo Dolicheno
There is no reference to Dolichenus in Pompeii that I can find. BUT! There is the famous hand of Sabazius.
More images below.
I mention this as Sabazius stands on a bull head and both cults use similar bronze hands.
The idea that these cults may have travelled back to Rome with soldier in the first century BCE is intriguing but unproved.
Other hands. I’ve taken these off pinterest as that is where I found the most images. I’ve not check for authenticity or source or findspot–use with caution
said to be in the National Aquatic Archaeological museum, Cartagena (Qart Hadasht – Carthago Nova)
said to be in the National Aquatic Archaeological museum, Cartagena (Qart Hadasht – Carthago Nova)Walters 542453
Today I accepted the official offer to serve next summer (their winter!) as a Senior Fellow at the Australian Centre for Ancient Numismatic Studies at MacQuarie University in Sydney, Australia. This will be for at least four weeks, precise dates to be announced. I am over the moon to be able to collaborate with all my Australian colleagues in real time without anyone sacrificing sleep for the zoom. It has been a life long dream to visit Australia in a fully immersive fashion.
I realize I’ve not yet announced my Visiting Professorship at the Institute of Advanced Study at the University of Warwick for “Spring”, 17 January – 17 March. (The pedant in me will point out the Spring equinox is after my return stateside.) This has been announced, but I owe them a head shot. The Warwick numismatic community is an inspiration so I hope to dream BIG and learn more about strategies integrating our discipline more fully into the study of the Ancient Mediterranean more broadly in terms of both curriculum and scholarship.
Headshots are so hard. I may need to phone a friend. I’m resolved to not use outdated photos as I age. If I don’t still wear the same glasses, the photo is too old.
This is part of my commitment to authenticity in myself presentation. There are too many pressures on young scholars and I remember all too well the haters on Mary Beard in her early days as a ‘media don’. To honor her trail blazing I want to keep my professional look authentically me, now. As I said to a young scholar in Beijing, a smart masters student at Capital Normal: one of the greatest joys as a woman is maturing and leaving behind the pressures to conform to societal expectations about femininity. The earlier we can make this internal transformation, the sooner we can embrace the gifts of our feminist foremothers.
The life of the mind and intellectual integrity exceeds any pleasure at being the object of esthetic admiration.
I do have photos of me from the last year I like but while they capture my joy and intensity, they aren’t quite the professional look of of a head shot. Definitely time to phone a photographer friend.
—
Right done with the ‘go, me!’ content and on to the workflow stuff. This is about Claude helping me organize my own materials both offline and online, past scholarship, reference images, and more to let me easily review and rewrite my conclusions and check them about the great and good of yesteryear. It also lets me see patterns and changes in interpretation. I could augment this further to hold my reference images for comparanda to support my conclusions but as the goal is a print publication, I do not want to spend the time or energy. Perfect is the enemy of done. For other similar applications it would be totally worth it. This took very little time to set up. An hour or so of my work day yesterday. The best part is as I check each entry, I can add new features instantaneous to make my work flow easier. For instance in the time it took me to write a couple sentences it added a back button to let me easily move between records when I’m checking one set of control marks against another. The only website Claude accessed to build this my own livyarrow.org. Otherwise, everything was on my hard drive and/or in my Dropbox.
Yes, Claude extracted all the info from Crawford, Babelon, Grueber, Sydenham, Leuthold (not relevant here), and Fava from scans I gave it. Yes it suggests likely similarities from the two series based on my own past work and verb similarity. Crawford and others were constrained by the costs of print and just ignored earlier interpretations with which they disagreed in many cases. We don’t have to do the same. I can sure my interventions are transparent and preserve the chain of interpretation. This is one form of progress: allowing the next generation to critique our work and prefer what came before.
It automatically tells me where to find my notes. I work in the right hand column editing my past language, updating, scoring, my confidence. Finalizing the text.
It will eventually output a final printable format and easily let me play around with that format until it displays my ideas in ways I think best reflect my unique intellectual interventions. I chose to screen shot a place were I break with all previous interpretations. Quite often I find I’m just reverting (or rather re discovering) what Grueber already knew more than a 100 years ago. Frustrating but also fascinating.
Although it is more laborious, I do like making up my own mind first. It helps my confidence that I’m not just following sheep-like along the accepted path. Conclusions in the humanities should be as replicable as in the sciences.
Will I one day let you play with my interfaces? Will I be making more complex interfaces? Absolutely! But it will take time. I need to find appropriate hosting to provide such access. It will probably in the first instance require a log-in. I’m hopeful CUNY will support this work or I will find other partners.
The future is bright.
Here’s some comparative images to support my claims about Papius no. 13 (RRC 384/1).